|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 11:54:09 GMT -6
Post by skinny51 on Feb 8, 2016 11:54:09 GMT -6
1. Brady 2. Montana 3. Manning 4. Farve 5. Elway, or Marino, or Young, or E. Manning, or Breeze, or Moon, or Bradshaw Then Aikman...
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 11:54:33 GMT -6
Post by skinny51 on Feb 8, 2016 11:54:33 GMT -6
turn that page, boi!
|
|
|
Post by fbs on Feb 8, 2016 11:56:40 GMT -6
I don't have bradshaw in my top 5. was a good qb for a team that ran the p!ss out of the ball and prided itself on defense. yes he's a hall of famer, but top 5 qb of all time? no sir. he's not close in any statistical category. he ran the plays that were called because he was too dumb to change the plays, that's a fact. I'm not a brady fan in any way shape or form, but my list goes like this: 1. Brady 2. Manning 3. Montana 4. Marino 5. Aikman 6. Elway 7. Favre 8. Kelly 9. Moon 10. Staubach
debateable for 6-10, could have been in there: Stabler, Starr, Unitas, Bradshaw, E. Manning, Roethlisberger, A. Rodgers...
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 11:59:58 GMT -6
Post by skinny51 on Feb 8, 2016 11:59:58 GMT -6
I don't have bradshaw in my top 5. was a good qb for a team that ran the p!ss out of the ball and prided itself on defense. yes he's a hall of famer, but top 5 qb of all time? no sir. he's not close in any statistical category. he ran the plays that were called because he was too dumb to change the plays, that's a fact. I'm not a brady fan in any way shape or form, but my list goes like this: 1. Brady 2. Manning 3. Montana 4. Marino 5. Aikman 6. Elway 7. Favre 8. Kelly 9. Moon 10. Staubach debateable for 6-10, could have been in there: Stabler, Starr, Unitas, Bradshaw, E. Manning, Roethlisberger, A. Rodgers... Nice list...just not feeling Aikman at 5...he was a modern day Bradshaw to me...that oline with Emmit and that defense made his job easy...the game wasn't on his shoulders week in and week out...he just managed and threw the ball to the likes of Harper, Ervin, and Novacke (spelling?)...
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 12:01:53 GMT -6
Post by Burnet44 on Feb 8, 2016 12:01:53 GMT -6
Super Bowl Montana Brady Bradshaw
All Time Brady Montana Peyton
IMHO
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 12:02:27 GMT -6
Post by Burnet44 on Feb 8, 2016 12:02:27 GMT -6
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 12:03:45 GMT -6
Post by washeduphasbeen on Feb 8, 2016 12:03:45 GMT -6
It's all conjecture and opinion, here's my two cents, which is probably not even worth two cents.
1. Manning 2. Brady 3. Bradshaw 4. Staubach 5. Elway
A lot of great qb's to choose from.
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 12:09:53 GMT -6
Post by TOBC on Feb 8, 2016 12:09:53 GMT -6
It's all conjecture and opinion, here's my two cents, which is probably not even worth two cents.
1. Manning 2. Brady 3. Bradshaw 4. Staubach 5. Elway
A lot of great qb's to choose from. which is why it's hard to come up with a solid list. everyone has their own criteria on which to base their comparisons.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 12:10:27 GMT -6
Post by Deleted on Feb 8, 2016 12:10:27 GMT -6
For me Peyton is the best. It showed when when manning was hurt for that year the colts went 2-14. When Brady was hurt cassell took the team to the playoffs. I dont think you can count a quarterback as the best ever based off super bowl rings. Way to much credit to one guy. best example is how manning just won the super bowl but if you watched he was by far and away not the reason the broncos won the superbowl.
1) manning 2) Brady 3) Montana/aikmen 4) marino
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 13:54:50 GMT -6
via mobile
Post by email on Feb 8, 2016 13:54:50 GMT -6
1. brady - 4 rings with completely different rosters every time...and without a dominant RB or WR at any time - aside from an end-of-his-career randy moss. 2. montana 3. everyone else What about Steve young?
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 13:56:36 GMT -6
via mobile
Post by email on Feb 8, 2016 13:56:36 GMT -6
1. Brady 2. Montana 3. Manning 4. Farve 5. Elway, or Marino, or Young, or E. Manning, or Breeze, or Moon, or Bradshaw Then Aikman... When did MOON play In a Super Bowl? And elway won at the end of his career with a dominate run game
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 13:57:47 GMT -6
Post by fbs on Feb 8, 2016 13:57:47 GMT -6
I don't have bradshaw in my top 5. was a good qb for a team that ran the p!ss out of the ball and prided itself on defense. yes he's a hall of famer, but top 5 qb of all time? no sir. he's not close in any statistical category. he ran the plays that were called because he was too dumb to change the plays, that's a fact. I'm not a brady fan in any way shape or form, but my list goes like this: 1. Brady 2. Manning 3. Montana 4. Marino 5. Aikman 6. Elway 7. Favre 8. Kelly 9. Moon 10. Staubach debateable for 6-10, could have been in there: Stabler, Starr, Unitas, Bradshaw, E. Manning, Roethlisberger, A. Rodgers... Nice list...just not feeling Aikman at 5...he was a modern day Bradshaw to me...that oline with Emmit and that defense made his job easy...the game wasn't on his shoulders week in and week out...he just managed and threw the ball to the likes of Harper, Ervin, and Novacke (spelling?)... I think I'd agree with that if it weren't for the fact that they all complimented each other so well. Aikman got the absolute h3ll beat out of him the first few years of his career, and it wasn't until all the pieces were put together that they were great. If that's your criteria then how can Montana even be on the list? Or Elway? Or Kelly? Or Staubach? Or Favre? If the criteria is that they made their team and their team is nothing without them then there are literally only two on the list, and that's manning and brady.
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 13:58:23 GMT -6
Post by fbs on Feb 8, 2016 13:58:23 GMT -6
1. brady - 4 rings with completely different rosters every time...and without a dominant RB or WR at any time - aside from an end-of-his-career randy moss. 2. montana 3. everyone else What about Steve young? touche... steve young is one of the top ten. didn't even think of him.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 8, 2016 17:25:50 GMT -6
Definitely a fun conversation.
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 8, 2016 17:37:17 GMT -6
via mobile
Post by email on Feb 8, 2016 17:37:17 GMT -6
And if Aaron Rodgers wins another I would think he's a top 7 guy too
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 9, 2016 8:06:57 GMT -6
Post by onemorerep on Feb 9, 2016 8:06:57 GMT -6
Montana Brady Manning Farve Bradshaw
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 9, 2016 8:11:13 GMT -6
via mobile
Post by skinny51 on Feb 9, 2016 8:11:13 GMT -6
1. Brady 2. Montana 3. Manning 4. Farve 5. Elway, or Marino, or Young, or E. Manning, or Breeze, or Moon, or Bradshaw Then Aikman... When did MOON play In a Super Bowl? And elway won at the end of his career with a dominate run game Exactly. I am not using super bowl appearances to determine who the GOAT is or to compile my list. Of course it is a factor but there is more too it than that. You can't deny Moon's stats and add his Canadian league stats to those. Moon was a stud. So if Breeze never gets back to the dance he doesn't deserve to be discussed here? I think he does with his body of work he has already compiled.
|
|
|
Post by Hands11 on Feb 9, 2016 8:12:34 GMT -6
Jim Kelly would be higher on my list! The dude went to 4 straight super bowls! If it wasn't for the "wide right" he would have a ring!
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 9, 2016 8:13:44 GMT -6
via mobile
Post by skinny51 on Feb 9, 2016 8:13:44 GMT -6
Have to have a lot of things go right to make it to the super bowl much less win more than one of them. Takes more than a QB to do what Brady or Montana has accomplished.
|
|
|
GOAT
Feb 9, 2016 9:16:02 GMT -6
email likes this
Post by fbs on Feb 9, 2016 9:16:02 GMT -6
Jim Kelly would be higher on my list! The dude went to 4 straight super bowls! If it wasn't for the "wide right" he would have a ring! for sure.
|
|